Search


 
 

New film depicts a genetically engineered, anti-gay future

Posted by Doug Pet on March 17th, 2011


What might the world look like if traits like eye color, athletic ability, and skin tone could be pre-programmed for a price, and characteristics like homosexuality were eliminated through government-enforced inoculation?

Director Nisha Ganatra explores these questions in her provocative new 20-minute film Beholder, which was recently released online and at film festivals. It inaugurates the second season of FutureStates, a Corporation for Public Broadcasting / Independent Television Service project in which ten established and up-and-coming filmmakers explore current social issues by playing them out decades in the future.

Beholder presents a chilling scenario in which hetero-normative prejudices are realized through state-mandated applications of genetic and reproductive technologies. In an interview with Biopolitical Times, Ganatra said she wants to challenge viewers to imagine a future in which "difference is not only undervalued, but has been voted out completely."


Beholder protagonist Sasha lives in an ultra-conservative ultra-exclusive gated community called Red Estates, where streets are immaculate, crime is non-existent, and children are genetically enhanced. Scientists have also pinpointed a genetic marker for homosexuality, which has been outlawed by way of mandatory screening and inoculations during pregnancy (or, it is implied, forced abortions).

When Sasha finds out that the baby she is expecting carries the "gay gene," her doctor assures her that the problem can be quickly and easily resolved, and a nurse entreats her in a sterile and eerily polite tone to "please sign the consent form for the mandatory inoculation." Tortured by the thought of altering her baby, Sasha poses the question, "what if my child would have a better life being who he is?"

Under the looming threat of the "Genetic Protection Agency," Sasha knows that a decision to refuse the inoculation would mean fleeing Red Estates for "the Coasts," a place - according to Red Estates propaganda - that is rife with violence, poverty, and other social ills. In a campaign speech, Sasha's politician husband explains:

Recent studies find that genetically enhanced children, lead happier, easier, more normal lives than the coast children. Don't let your child be left behind!... Red Estates is a model city-genetically, morally, politically superior to everything beyond those borders. There are rules that make Red Estates great, and we have to live by those rules. For the greater good…No matter what the personal sacrifices.
Ganatra shrewdly shows how ideologies that champion using technologies "for the greater good" often disenfranchise, and in this case eugenically eliminate, those who have less power and have been deemed socially problematic. She told Biopolitical Times that it was her anger and disappointment over California's Prop 8 that led her to explore the question, "what happens when the majority can take away the rights a of a minority group?" Having come face to face in her own life with the emerging social and ethical questions around selecting sperm donors and their traits, Ganatra decided to unpack this question through the lens of reproductive technologies.

She added that her goal, and that of the FutureStates project as a whole, is not to deliver overly fantastic or dystopic stories but to capture the social realities of the present and predict their consequences for social justice in the not-so-distant future. "The great thing about sci-fi," she said, "is that one gets to ask the question, what if this wasn't just the worst-case scenario? What if that was only the beginning?"

Some sci-fi movies dwell on futuristic technological enchantments. In Beholder, Ganatra chillingly and persuasively shows what might happen if the social injustices of today are channeled through the technological possibilities of tomorrow.



Posted in A "Post-Human" Future?, Arts & Culture, Assisted Reproduction, Doug Pet's Blog Posts, Eugenics, Genetic Selection, Inheritable Genetic Modification, LGBTQI, Media Coverage, Reproductive Justice, Health & Rights, Sex Selection


Comments

Add a Comment
  1. Comment by fdasfds, Mar 12th, 2012 7:16am

    While economic concerns still linger, Ralph Lauren Pas Cher it appears that many retailers have reason to be cheerful: retailers surveyed for Q1 2011 vs. 925 Silver Jewelry a year earlier report that the average growth in web sales was a respectable 28 percent. Fifty-five retailers participated in the anonymous Quarterly Online Sales Flash Survey, conducted jointly by Shop.org and Forrester Research from April 1 to 5, 2011. Casques Monster Beats 2011 Flash Surveys - Avg Q1 YOY growth by type of retailer Indeed, Jeans Pas Cher multichannel primarily store-based retailers as well as branded manufacturers reported year-over-year growth for the quarter of 33 percent; ditto for retailers boasting between $10 million and $100 million in annual Web revenue. Comments on Q1 trends observed included the negative impact on sales from recent major world events and monster energy pas cher a later-than-usual Easter this year. By contrast, one retailer noted that the severe weather in January and February had actually boosted their bottom line. Still, Chemise Buberry Pas Cher the market is perplexing: for some retailers, average order value was up, though not for others. Chaussures Dolce Gabbana and while one retailer observed that free shipping has become a consumer expectation, another noted that they had cut off free shipping offers with no palpable impact on sales. While the elusive “silver bullet” continues to be just that – elusive – it appears that consumers overall are showing signs of continued confidence. Paul Smith Sale Shop.org members can download the full results summary here. As obvious as it sounds, Dre Monster Beats retailers should continue to test what works for their customers (hats off to the retailer noted above who cut off free shipping to test the impact on sales) and make sure that all the basics are working as they should. If you haven’t checked out the growing list of expert insights on topics spanning testing, video merchandising, mobile commerce strategies and tactics, Cheap Armani Shirts even how to hire the right leaders for your multichannel organization, check out the ever growing Shop.org White Paper Library.


 


ESPAÑOL | PORTUGUÊS | Русский

home | overview | blog | publications | about us | donate | newsletter | press room | privacy policy

CGS • 1936 University Ave, Suite 350, Berkeley, CA 94704 USA • • (p) 1.510.625.0819 • (F) 1.510.665.8760